Real homes, real budgets, real cozy

Living Room

14 Brick Fireplace Makeover Ideas From Real Homes

By Hana · Updated · 8 min read

Three brick fireplace makeovers: painted stone with an arched top, a German schmear arched fireplace and light schmeared brick

A brick fireplace makeover can change the whole feel of a room. Paint, limewash, German schmear or new stone each give a very different look.

Here are 14 brick fireplace makeover ideas from real homes, with the method and finish each one used.

14 Brick Fireplace Makeover Ideas From Real Homes

1A Subtle Painted Finish on Stone

View this post by jennifermaune on Instagram

Photo: jennifermaune on Instagram (Not confirmed)

She shared a before and after fireplace transformation and offers her step by step process for painting brick or stone for a long lasting finish. She used Sherwin-Williams finishes for a subtle change. The gray stone surround has a carved arched top and a wood bench in front.

A subtle color shift can update a fireplace without losing the texture of the stone.

How to get this look

  1. Clean the brick or stone well first.
  2. Use a masonry primer and paint.
  3. Pick a shade close to the original for a subtle change.
🧱 Method: Paint💲 Budget: $80 to $250✨ Finish: Matte masonry paint🎨 Style: Old world

2German Schmear Over an Arched Opening

View this post by puredesigninc on Instagram

Photo: puredesigninc on Instagram (Not confirmed)

This designer kept the original brick fireplace's arched opening and arched hearth and gave it a fresh update with a German schmear. The mortar wash softens the brick while some red still shows through.

German schmear keeps the brick texture but tones it down, so an older fireplace looks aged on purpose.

How to get this look

  1. Mix a mortar wash.
  2. Smear it over the brick by hand.
  3. Wipe some off so bits of brick show through.
🧱 Method: German schmear💲 Budget: $50 to $150✨ Finish: Mortar wash🎨 Style: Cottage

3From Orange Brick to Light and Bright

View this post by at_home_with_britt on Instagram

Photo: at_home_with_britt on Instagram (Not confirmed)

She highly recommends a German schmear for an old brick fireplace. She took her brick from orangey and dated to light and bright with lots of character, and says it has held up well.

If your brick is orange or red, a schmear brings it to soft white without a flat painted look.

How to get this look

  1. Test the schmear on a small patch.
  2. Work in small sections.
  3. Leave some brick showing for character.
🧱 Method: German schmear💲 Budget: $50 to $150✨ Finish: White mortar🎨 Style: Modern farmhouse

4A Whitewashed Fireplace With Layered Mirrors

View this post by soulandlane on Instagram

Photo: soulandlane on Instagram (Not confirmed)

This account shared a white washed brick fireplace and points out the mantel styled with layered mirrors, frames and vases with blush accents. The photo is from purelychichome.

A whitewash keeps a light, airy look. Layered mirrors on the mantel add height and soft reflection.

How to get this look

  1. Whitewash the brick with thinned paint.
  2. Lean two mirrors on the mantel.
  3. Add vases and soft blush accents.
🧱 Method: Whitewash💲 Budget: $40 to $120✨ Finish: Layered mirrors🎨 Style: Soft farmhouse

5Salvaged Brick and New Trim

View this post by hind.sight.vintage on Instagram

Photo: hind.sight.vintage on Instagram (Not confirmed)

She says her fireplace had a slow glow up. It was already painted white when she bought the house, and sandblasting was not an option. She salvaged brick from the exterior to fill in the top, then added trim to the top and sides.

When brick is already painted, add trim and a new color instead of trying to strip it.

How to get this look

  1. Fill gaps with salvaged brick.
  2. Add trim around the top and sides.
  3. Paint the whole surround one deep color.
🧱 Method: Paint and trim💲 Budget: $100 to $400✨ Finish: Salvaged brick🎨 Style: Vintage eclectic

6A Simple Coat of White Paint

View this post by lyleteamrealtors on Instagram

Photo: lyleteamrealtors on Instagram (Not confirmed)

This realtor team says a coat of paint on the bricks can transform the look of a fireplace and the whole room, and calls it a good weekend DIY project. A white painted brick fireplace sits beside built-in shelves with a round mirror above.

Paint is the fastest, cheapest way to change a dated brick fireplace.

How to get this look

  1. Clean and prime the brick.
  2. Paint it white with masonry paint.
  3. Hang a round mirror above.
🧱 Method: Paint💲 Budget: $50 to $150✨ Finish: White paint🎨 Style: Clean classic

7A Smooth Glow Up for a Small Living Room

View this post by kathleencaseydesign on Instagram

Photo: kathleencaseydesign on Instagram (Not confirmed)

This designer says this dated brick fireplace glow up made a huge impact in a small living room. She thanks ClassicFireplaceBBQstore and MCKcustomwalls for the work. The new surround is smooth and plain with a wood beam mantel.

Covering busy brick with a smooth surface makes a small room feel calmer and bigger.

How to get this look

  1. Cover the brick with a smooth surround.
  2. Add a simple wood beam mantel.
  3. Keep decor light on the mantel.
🧱 Method: Resurface💲 Budget: $1,000 to $4,000✨ Finish: Wood beam mantel🎨 Style: Modern organic

8Red Brick Replaced With Limestone

View this post by interiorsbyseashal on Instagram

Photo: interiorsbyseashal on Instagram (Not confirmed)

This designer replaced a red brick fireplace with limestone and natural stone, a birch log insert, new crown molding and a seamless grass woven wallpaper.

A full replacement costs more, but stone and grasscloth give a warm, high end look.

How to get this look

  1. Remove the old brick facing.
  2. Install limestone or natural stone.
  3. Add grasscloth wallpaper around it.
🧱 Method: Replace💲 Budget: $3,000 and up✨ Finish: Limestone🎨 Style: Warm traditional

9A Bold Black Painted Fireplace

View this post by dixiebellepaint on Instagram

Photo: dixiebellepaint on Instagram (Not confirmed)

This paint brand shared a brick fireplace makeover with Onyx Terra Clay Paint for a bold, modern look. The deep black finish adds dramatic contrast. A wood beam mantel and round mirror sit above the black brick.

Black brick looks modern and hides soot. A wood mantel keeps it warm.

How to get this look

  1. Paint the brick a matte black.
  2. Add a natural wood mantel.
  3. Style with a round mirror and greenery.
🧱 Method: Paint💲 Budget: $60 to $150✨ Finish: Black clay paint🎨 Style: Modern rustic

10A DIY Whitewash

View this post by jameskwontx on Instagram

Photo: jameskwontx on Instagram (Not confirmed)

This account says whitewashing a brick fireplace is easy and brings new appreciation to the focal point of a room. A whitewashed brick fireplace has a black insert and a green wreath.

Whitewash is cheap, quick and lets some brick color peek through.

How to get this look

  1. Mix white paint and water.
  2. Brush it on and wipe back.
  3. Add a wreath for a finished look.
🧱 Method: Whitewash💲 Budget: $30 to $80✨ Finish: Thinned white paint🎨 Style: Farmhouse

11Limewashed Brick With a Black Mantel

View this post by houselogic on Instagram

Photo: houselogic on Instagram (Not confirmed)

This home site says painting a dated brick fireplace could be the transformation a room needs, and points to its guide on the benefits and challenges. A soft limewashed brick fireplace has a floating black mantel.

A floating black mantel gives soft, light brick a crisp line.

How to get this look

  1. Limewash the brick in a soft white.
  2. Mount a floating black mantel.
  3. Keep decor to a few pieces.
🧱 Method: Limewash💲 Budget: $50 to $150✨ Finish: Black mantel🎨 Style: Modern farmhouse

12A Brick Wall Painted in One Day

View this post by tommystouch on Instagram

Photo: tommystouch on Instagram (Not confirmed)

This painter says he hand painted this interior brick fireplace wall makeover in one day. The brick now has a light limewash look with a darker hearth.

A full brick wall can be refreshed in a day with the right painter.

How to get this look

  1. Hire a painter for a one day refresh.
  2. Pick a limewash or whitewash look.
  3. Leave the hearth a darker tone.
🧱 Method: Limewash💲 Budget: $300 to $800✨ Finish: Hand painted🎨 Style: Classic

13A Thin Brick Remodel

View this post by oldmillbp on Instagram

Photo: oldmillbp on Instagram (Not confirmed)

This brick maker shared a brick fireplace remodel, reposted from nrwinterboer, using thin brick. A light brick surround frames a fireplace with a TV above and a wood mantel.

Thin brick veneer lets you add real brick texture over drywall or old surrounds.

How to get this look

  1. Apply thin brick veneer over the old surround.
  2. Add a wood mantel.
  3. Mount the TV above if needed.
🧱 Method: Thin brick💲 Budget: $800 to $2,500✨ Finish: Brick veneer🎨 Style: Modern farmhouse

14Leave the Exposed Brick

View this post by tristanbills on Instagram

Photo: tristanbills on Instagram (Not confirmed)

This account says an exposed brick fireplace adds so much character. A tall natural brick wall stands next to white built-in shelves and a cozy chair.

Sometimes the best makeover is styling around the brick, not covering it.

How to get this look

  1. Keep the brick natural.
  2. Add white built-ins beside it.
  3. Use warm, cozy textiles nearby.
🧱 Method: Keep natural💲 Budget: $0 to $200✨ Finish: Exposed brick🎨 Style: Classic cottage

For more cozy rooms, see my basement family room ideas .

How to Plan a Brick Fireplace Makeover

  1. Decide if you want to cover the brick or keep its texture.
  2. Clean the brick well with a stiff brush.
  3. Test your paint, limewash or schmear on a hidden spot.
  4. Use products made for masonry.
  5. Work in small sections from top to bottom.
  6. Update the mantel and hearth to match the new look.

Budget Tips for a Brick Fireplace Makeover

  • Whitewash or limewash is the cheapest option.
  • Paint is reversible only with effort, so test first.
  • Reuse your mantel and just refinish it.
  • Save stone or thin brick for when the budget allows.

Hana’s tip: Limewash is the easiest finish to fix. If you do not like it, you can scrub some off while it is still fresh.

FAQs About Brick Fireplace Makeovers

Can you paint a brick fireplace?

Yes. Clean it, use a masonry primer and paint made for brick, and keep paint off the inside firebox.

What is the difference between limewash and whitewash?

Limewash is a lime based finish that soaks into brick. Whitewash is thinned paint brushed on and wiped back.

What is a German schmear?

It is a mortar wash smeared over brick and partly wiped off for an old world look.

How much does a brick fireplace makeover cost?

A DIY paint or limewash can cost under $150. New stone or thin brick can cost a few thousand dollars.

Final Thoughts

A fresh fireplace can be the start of a whole new living room. For more ideas, see my farmhouse living room decor and sofa table decor.